This article was posted 08/14/2008 and is most likely outdated.

How much working space is enough?
 

 

Topic - NEC
Subject - How much working space is enough?

August 14, 2008
This newsletter was sent to 29653 newsletter subscribers

Ask a Question |  Weekly Code GraphicQuizzes |  Free Stuff InstructorsOnline Training Products | Seminars | SubscribeUnsubscribe
[ image1 Post Comments | View Comments | Notify Me When Comments Are Added ] Web Page Version [Printer-Friendly]    

How much working space is enough?

 

By Mike Holt for EC&M Magazine

 

Don’t assume three feet of working space applies in all situations.

 

OSHA and the NEC [110.26] provide working space requirements that vary with conditions. The NEC starts 110.26 by stating the space must be sufficient for “ready and safe operation and maintenance” of the electrical equipment.

That single condition both underlies and overrides all else in 110.26.

 

When interpreting and applying the requirements, the goal isn’t to see what you can get by with. The goal is to protect people and property. Consequently, you may need to exceed the numbers given in 110.26 to satisfy the intent of 110.26. Think through the work process. For example, is there enough room to safely use a lifting boom on that heavy breaker?

 

Requirement exceptions

 

Per 90.3, the working space requirements of 110.26 don’t apply to equipment included in Chapter 8. However, signaling and communications equipment can’t encroach on the working space of the electrical equipment.

 

The NEC doesn’t require working space for the back or sides of an assembly where all connections and all renewable or adjustable parts are accessible from the front. “Accessible” is the key word, here; read the Article 100 definition.

Where special permission is granted per 90.4, working space for equipment that operates at not more than 30V ac or 60V dc can be less than the distance in Table 110.26(A)(1). Read the definition of “Special Permission” in Article 100.

If you’re replacing electrical equipment, you can apply Table 110.26 Condition 2 working space requirements between dead-front switchboards, panelboards, or motor control centers located across the aisle from each other. But only if:

 

  • Conditions of maintenance and supervision ensure that written procedures have been adopted to prohibit equipment on both sides of the aisle from being open at the same time, and
  • Only authorized, qualified persons will service the installation.

Width, depth, and height

 

A common area of disagreement is the phrase “while energized” in 110.26(A), which says, “Equipment that may need examination, adjustment, servicing, or maintenance while energized must have sufficient working space in accordance with (1), (2), and (3)….”  Get clarification on what “while energized” means from the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ).

 

In all cases, the working space must be of sufficient width, depth, and height to permit all equipment doors to open 90 degrees.

 

The width of the working space must be a minimum of 30 in., but in no case less than the width of the equipment.

 

You can measure the width of the working from left-to-right, from right-to-left, or simply centered on the equipment. The working space for one piece of equipment can overlap the working space for other electrical equipment.

 

See Table 110.26(A)(1) for the minimum depth required of a specific application. It’s not always three feet. For example, it’s 4 ft at a 480V MCC with exposed live parts on both sides of the working space.

 

“Headroom” is another way we refer to the height of a working space. For service equipment, switchboards, panelboards, and motor control equipment, the headroom in front of equipment must be at least 6½ ft, measured from the grade, floor, or platform [110.26(E)]. For equipment over 6½ ft in height, the headroom can’t be less than the height of the equipment.

 

Exception: The minimum headroom requirement doesn’t apply to service equipment or panelboards rated 200A or less in an existing dwelling unit. See the definition of “Dwelling Unit” in Article 100.

 

Equipment such as raceways, cables, wireways, cabinets, and panels can be above or below electrical equipment, but must not extend more than 6 in. into the equipment working space.

 

Clear spaces

 

Working space covered by 110.26 must be clear at all times [110.26(B)]. Therefore, it can’t double as a storage area. It’s dangerous to service energized parts in the first place. It’s unacceptable to subject electrical workers to the additional dangers of working around boxes, cabinets, and other impediments in their working space.

 

When normally enclosed live parts are exposed for inspection or servicing in a passageway, the working space must be suitably guarded from occupants using the passageway. Make allowances for a fire alarm evacuation, which will have numerous occupants moving through the passageway.

 

Entrance and Egress

 

At least one entrance of sufficient area must provide access to and egress from the working space [110.26(C)(1)]. Building codes contain minimum dimensions for doors and openings for personnel travel. Check with the AHJ for clarification of “sufficient area.”

 

You must have an entrance to and egress from separate ends of the working space of electrical equipment rated 1,200A or more, if the equipment is over 6 ft wide. The opening must be not less than 24 in. wide and 6½ ft high. You can have a single entrance/egress at one end, if:

 

  • The location permits a continuous and unobstructed way of egress travel, or.
  • The required working space depth is doubled, and the equipment is located so the edge of the entrance is no closer than the required working space distance.

Where equipment with overcurrent or switching devices rated 1,200A or more is installed, personnel door(s) for entrance to and egress from the working space located less than 25 ft from the nearest edge of the working space must have the door(s) open in the direction of egress and be equipped with panic hardware or other devices that open under simple pressure.

 

Electricians who suffer burns on their hands in electrical arc flash or arc blast events often can’t open doors equipped with knobs that must be turned. Since this requirement is in the NEC, the electrical contractor is responsible for ensuring that panic hardware is installed where required. Some electrical contractors chafe at being held liable for nonelectrical responsibilities, but this rule exists to save the lives of electricians.

 

Illumination

 

Service equipment, switchboards, panelboards, and motor control centers located indoors must have illumination in (or next to) the working space [110.26(D)]. Illumination must not be controlled by automatic means only.

 

The NEC doesn’t provide the minimum foot-candles required for proper illumination, but lighting application guides do. Proper illumination of electrical equipment rooms is essential for the safety of those working on such equipment.

 

Saving a few bucks on installed lighting only to incur the costs of temporary lighting or extended downtime later isn’t good economics. But this isn’t a matter of just economics. The safety issue makes good lighting not just sensible, but imperative.

 

Dedicated space

 

Switchboards, panelboards, and motor control centers must have dedicated equipment space and be protected from damage [110.26(F).

 

Outdoor equipment must comply with 110.26(F)(2). For indoor equipment, the following requirements apply.

 

  • The footprint space (width and depth of the equipment) extending from the floor to a height of 6 ft above the equipment or to the structural ceiling, whichever is lower, must be dedicated for the electrical installation. No piping, ducts, or other equipment foreign to the electrical installation can be installed in this dedicated footprint space.

Exception: Suspended ceilings with removable panels can be within the dedicated footprint space [110.26(G)].

 

  • Electrical raceways and cables not associated with the dedicated space can be within the dedicated space. These aren’t considered “equipment foreign to the electrical installation.”
  • Foreign systems can be located above the dedicated space if protection is installed to prevent damage to the electrical equipment from condensation, leaks, or breaks in the foreign systems.
  • Sprinkler protection piping isn’t permitted in the dedicated space, but the NEC doesn’t prohibit sprinklers from spraying water on electrical equipment.
  • A dropped, suspended, or similar ceiling isn’t considered a structural ceiling.
  • Electrical equipment rooms and enclosures housing electrical equipment or apparatus controlled by locks are considered accessible to qualified persons who require access.

See the definition of “Accessible as it applies to equipment” in Article 100.

 

Now you can answer the question of how much working space is enough. And you know that a correct answer depends on what space you’re talking about, what equipment is in that space, and other factors. The distance tables in OSHA and in 110.26 are starting points, not maximums.

 

What you’re really trying to do is ensure that the space around the equipment doesn’t prevent the safe operation and maintenance of that equipment. Meet that goal, and you’ll satisfy OSHA, the NEC, and your insurance company. None of these are concerned, however, with the efficiency of maintenance and operation.

 

Often, people want to reduce working space in a misguided effort to maximize revenue per square foot for the facility. The reality is that you maximize revenue per square foot only when you allow enough space for efficient operation, maintenance, and repair.

 

 

 

Click here to post a comment
[ View More Newsletters ] [ Send to a Friend ] [ Post Comments | View Comments | Notify Me When Comments Are Added ]

Copyright © Mike Holt Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved.
This article is protected by United States copyright and other intellectual property laws and may not be
displayed or published on the internet without the prior written permission of Mike Holt Enterprises, Inc.

http://www.MikeHolt.com     1-888-NEC-CODE (1-888-632-2633)

Experiencing a Problem? Click Here

 
Comments
  • A creative Electrician once pointed out that there is nothing in the code preventing a panel from being hung on the ceiling, as long as the main breaker is no more than 6 feet off the floor, and there is three feet of working space toward the floor in front of the panel. So you could put a transformer on the floor under the panel, he jokes. He said this in jest, but he had actually hung panels upside down on the wall, with the main breaker no more than 6 feet from the ground and the rest of the panel up in the air!

    Anybody ever hang a panel upside down, with the main breaker at six feet?

    lawrence
    Reply to this comment
  • Reply from: JOSE A GUILLEN   
    If the breakers switches are in the upright position yes it matters because once you flip your panel box upside down it will be a code violation to swap up for off and down for on read article 110. and also chapter 2 and 4 it would be to me noncompliance/ code violation/ and a stop order would be written up on this installation.
    Reply to JOSE A GUILLEN


  • Mike, this is really well done examination of this feature of the safety codes. Unfortunately, most inspectors won't read it. I have seen them come up with insane interpretations. We had to move a 2000 HP motor 11 inches inches back because of a post 3 inches wide almost 4 feet from the panel that was not obstructing the doors or equipment service.

    Bob
    Reply to this comment

  • Mike

    I do not recall where I found this commentary and it worth passing it on to everyone at this time

    Insufficient working space [110.32]. In a misguided attempt to maximize revenue per square foot, people often nitpick code requirements to determine the absolute minimums for working space. They fail to realize that working space is an investment, not a cost. Cramped working space is unsafe, and it inhibits the very maintenance that prevents downtime. It also extends downtime by making repairs difficult and unsafe. This is why the first words of 110.32 are "Sufficient space." Using the 3-foot minimum clearance as the maximum clearance [110.33]. OSHA and the NEC do not, as commonly misunderstood, dictate you must provide exactly 3 feet of clearance (or maybe a little less, if you can hold your ruler at an angle) in front of energized parts. In fact, the minimum may be more than 3 feet (Table 110.34(A) and OSHA 1926.403). Operational and other issues might provide bottom-line reasons to go beyond NEC and OSHA requirements.

    wyrenutt
    Reply to this comment
  • Reply from: JOSE A GUILLEN   
    wyrenut i also think the way you do yes in the interest of safety lets go beyond minimum requirements than to be exactly on the border line the inspector's we think like you
    Reply to JOSE A GUILLEN


  • Having served as an electrical inspector for 18 years out of 45 years as a licensed electrician in MA. I question the following 110-26 rule. A clear and unobstructed exit in case of injury. How about the practice of the large box stores of placing the electric room on a mezzanine deck to save space, typically they provide access to this room by a straight wall ladder. I will not accept this arrangement as I feel it does not comply as a safe access in event of injury. I have insisted on a stairway for access. What is your opinion?

    Leo P. Landry Sr.
    Reply to this comment

  • I fully agree on sufficient working space around electrical equipment, panelboards, load centers, motor controllers, etc. As an electrician it was sometimes quite a task trying to repair something with no room to work. Having said that, I am constantly having problems with non-fusuable disconnect clearances for geo thermal equipment. Does anybody know why the same clearances apply to non-fuseable disconnects installed for equipment maintenance when they can be de-energized for maintenance and repair without affecting anything else but the equipment they service.

    Jim
    Reply to this comment

  • What many people fail to reealize is the difference between the working space and the room that contains it. If the room is larger than the working space then there is no need for panic hardware. 110.26(C)(2)

    Working space in front of a non-fusible switch? Not required in my opinion.

    I think there have been many attempts to get a stronger statement here one way or the other, but the CMP won\'t go for it.

    Larry LeVoir
    Reply to this comment

  • Thats a good idea to have the panic hardware on the electrical room doors.....

    Terry Mc
    Reply to this comment
  • Reply from: JOSE A GUILLEN   
    NOW IN THE 2008 N.E.C THAT IS A REQUIREMENT AT ARTICLE 110.
    Reply to JOSE A GUILLEN



Get notified when new comments are posted here
* Your Email:
 
        
 
Add Your Comments to this Newsletter
* Your Name:
   Your name will appear under your comments.

* Your Email:
   Your email address is not displayed.
* Comments:

Email Notification Options:
Notify me when a reply is posted to this comment
Notify me whenever a comment is posted to this newsletter