Mike Holt Business Newlsetter Series

Mike Holt's Rating of the Electrical Industry - 2022


June 11, 2022
Share: Facebook Twitter

As part of my ongoing focus on electrical safety, we update our annual report that assigns a grade to U.S. states for electrical standards that are mandated state-wide. I've had feedback to say that there is a state that has a "good grade" but that state is renowned for the worst electrical wiring! Or that, even though a state requires electrical inspectors to be certified, there are rural areas in that state to which no inspectors are assigned!

I recognize that there are a lot of individuals that are passionate about electrical safety, and they do everything that they can to introduce laws and measures in their communities to achieve those goals. I salute them and their efforts. All we can do here with this report, is standardize the measurable criteria that we can apply across the board to compare the efforts that each state is making.
How does your state rank?

Congratulations!
To the following states with an A+ ranking:

Delaware, Iowa, Maine, Minnesota, North Dakota, Oregon, South Dakota, Wyoming.

 
Criteria Used for Grading
The following criteria are all required at the state level for points to be assigned for this report:
(Note: all 12 points are required for an A+ grade)
  • The NEC edition adopted (range -2 for local to +3 points for current, 2020 NEC); the NEC must be adopted and required by the state as the minimum standard in all counties and municipalities
  • Licensing and/or certification is required for Apprentice, Journeyman, Master/Contractor, Inspector, and Engineer licenses (5 points max.)
  • Continuing Education (CEU, CPC or PDH) is required for license renewal (4 points max.)

 

 
CEU Grading
With hundreds of changes happening in the Code, and changes in materials available, continuing education is more important than ever. This is why we have broken down state requirements to a standard unit of average hours required annually. While the requirement for CEUs for license renewal is already taken into account in the safety grading system, we thought it would be important to also take a more in-depth look at the number of hours required by each state for their electrical license renewal. For that reason, we created a stand-alone rating system for CEUs. Click here to see the Continuing Education chart.

 

 

What we cannot consider
Local Adoptions. We recognize that many counties and municipalities adopt the most recent building and electrical codes ahead of their state. We commend them for continuing to set high standards in electrical safety! For this State Report, however, they are too numerous to include.

Enforcement or effectiveness. We are unaware of a way to track or correlate enforcement as it relates to rates of incidents, electrical fires or accidents. We're always looking for ways, so if you have a criteria which we could apply evenly across all states, please reach out to us.

  How does your state rank?

For history and details of how grades are calculated, click here.
Note: All 12 points are required for an A+ grade.

We'd appreciate your feedback.
If you have any updated information that you feel would change our rankings on this year's report, please post your comment - we appreciate your input to help keep this analysis accurate and current.

 

STATE NAME 2018 GRADE 2019 GRADE 2020 GRADE 2021 GRADE 2022 GRADE
ALABAMA B B B- B- B-
ALASKA A A+ A A A
ARIZONA F F F F F
ARKANSAS A+ A+ A A A
CALIFORNIA A- A- A- A- A-
COLORADO A+ A+ A- A A
CONNECTICUT A- A A- A- A-
DELAWARE A A A- A- A+
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA C C C C+ C+
FLORIDA B B B- B B
GEORGIA B- B- C+ B- B-
HAWAII C+ B- C+ C+ C+
IDAHO A A A- A- A-
ILLINOIS F F F F F
INDIANA D D F F F
IOWA A+ A+ A A+ A+
KANSAS F F F F F
KENTUCKY A- A A- A- A-
LOUISIANA C+ C+ C C C
MAINE A+ A+ A A A+
MARYLAND C C C+ C+ C+
MASSACHUSETTS A- A- A- A- A-
MICHIGAN A A+ A A A
MINNESOTA A+ A+ A A+ A+
MISSISSIPPI F F F F F
MISSOURI F F F F F
MONTANA A- A- B+ A- A-
NEBRASKA A+ A+ A A A
NEVADA F F F D D
NEW HAMPSHIRE A- A- B+ B+ B+
NEW JERSEY A- A- A- A- A-
NEW MEXICO A- A- B+ B+ B+
NEW YORK C+ C+ C C+ C+
NORTH CAROLINA B+ B+ B B B+
NORTH DAKOTA A+ A+ A A+ A+
OHIO B B B- B- B-
OKLAHOMA A- A- B+ B+ A-
OREGON A+ A+ A A+ A+
PENNSYLVANIA C+ C+ C C C+
RHODE ISLAND B+ B+ B+ B+ A-
SOUTH CAROLINA B- B- B- B- B-
SOUTH DAKOTA A+ A+ A A+ A+
TENNESSEE B B B- B- B-
TEXAS A- A- B+ A- A-
UTAH A A A- A- A
VERMONT A- A- B+ B+ A-
VIRGINIA B+ A- B+ B+ A-
WASHINGTON A A A- A A
WEST VIRGINIA B B B- B B+
WISCONSIN A- A- B+ B+ B+
WYOMING A+ A+ A A+ A+
Comments
  • Hawaii is going through transition of new electrical inspectors and it seems to be moving towards a positive way for the electrical industry. Not like in the past, the older generation of inspectors wouldn’t share any knowledge but condemn the up and coming electrician’s. Why, I don’t know? It would be best if we were on the same page when it comes to being code compliant in the electrical trade.

    Hopefully, we get there.

    AC  June 11 2022, 5:49 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • Would be interesting to see the data as a correlation between accidental deaths due to Shocks, ESD, and fire caused by poor installation practices. Of course association and causal effect can be rather spurious and self serving in determining clear causation.

    David Buckley   June 11 2022, 4:40 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • Georgia is even safer now that we passed constitutional carry! Now it’s your turn to help out Governor DeSantis get it passed in Florida Mike.

    Paul Jennison   June 11 2022, 3:00 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • Based on the criteria would Florida have scored higher if it wasn’t a code cycle behind?

    SoFloBuc  June 11 2022, 2:47 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment
  • Reply from: Paula   June 21 2022, 1:57 pm EDT
    Yes, Florida would have a B+ rating (one more point) if it were on the 2020 NEC.
    Reply to Paula



Get notified when new comments are posted here
* Your Email:
 
        
 
Add Your Comments to this Newsletter
* Your Name:
   Your name will appear under your comments.

* Your Email:
   Your email address is not displayed.
* Comments:

Email Notification Options:
Notify me when a reply is posted to this comment
Notify me whenever a comment is posted to this newsletter