This article was posted 08/15/2005 and is most likely outdated.

First-hand Lightning Experience
 

 
Topic - Lightning and Surge Protection
Subject - First-hand Lightning Experience

August 15, 2005 

| Ask a Question |  Code Graphic Code Quiz Free Stuff Instructors | Feedback
Online Training Products | Seminars | SubscribeUnsubscribe |
Change Email Address |
  Send to a Friend Web Page Version [Printer-Friendly]    

First-hand Lightning Experience

Mike,

Your recent free online training video via your newsletter reminded me of several observations I acquired from my first hand lightning experience two years ago. I was at Tomahawk Scout camp near Rice Lake Wisconsin at the time. The rain had started in earnest and all of the scouts had just reported to their merit badge classes (mostly outdoors!). The camp wisely made the decision to keep the scouts together in their class locations instead of having them spread all over the camp for the next thirty minutes while they were sent back to their campsites, which also offered limited shelter. I was walking down a dirt road dressed in my usual wet weather gear; which is basically nylon shorts, a non-cotton t-shirt, and sandals.

A large lightning strike to a 75-year old oak tree occurred 100 feet away from me. The heat from the current flowing through the trunk vaporized the water in the wood and raised the internal pressure to a point where the trunk ruptured along a twenty-foot length. One fragment 4 feet long and about 4 inches in cross section made it half way to me. Small fragments of the core were strewn all over the area for 75 feet.

An arc in air from several feet up the trunk was observed going directly to the earth. Apparently the impedance change in the trunk near the ground was sufficient to allow a parallel path to ground outside the trunk.

The current flowed horizontally in the earth in most every direction through whatever parallel paths were available. Depending on the soil conditions, this might not necessarily be as much a surface current as your golf green picture and instead may have a significant depth. In any case, about seventy feet from the lightning strike, a long abandoned, buried, 16-3 extension cord was running at mostly right angles to the current radiating from the tree. This optimal conductor had such a high current flowing through it even though it was at right angles to the ground current, that it vaporized and blew out a trench of dirt twelve inches deep along it's length.

A scout leaning against a metal freezer wall in a cement floor building 500 feet away was shocked by a touch potential. I observed, but did not feel, a spark jump between my big toe and ground. I am not sure, but I expect this might have been an equalization of static charge impressed on my body from the high electric field. Lessons learned from this incident, along with your tutelage on stray and leakage current, are that you do not want to be a parallel conductor for this amazingly high current flowing in the ground. Just like freshwater drowning from electric shock, we are a pretty good conductor when compared to earth.

So don't lie on the ground in a storm. Instead support yourself as best you can on two feet placed close together. Find an insulating layer such as a lifejacket, or sleeping pad to squat on with both feet close together. Do not support yourself with your hands. I also conclude that permanent picnic shelters, typically without side walls or floor, are not adequate protection since current can pass across the ground underneath.

Cheers,
Ken Lillemo, Shoreview , MN

[ View More Newsletters ] Please Reply With Your Comments

2 0 0 5   G r o u n d i n g   v e r s u s   B o n d i n g   S e m i n a r s
 TOPIC  LOCATION  SPONSOR  INFORMATION
October 11st thru
October 12nd
Mike Holt, EC&M & Leviton: Grounding versus Bonding
Boston, MA
Boston Convention & Exhibition Center
415 Summer Street
(617) 954-2000
Mike Holt Enterprises, EC&M Magazine & Leviton
Email Donna Brown
Phone: (866) 632-2633
[ Download Brochure ]
[ Preview Video ] Download Quicktime Player [FREE]
[ Register Both Days ]
October 17th thru
October 18th
Mike Holt, EC&M & Leviton: Grounding versus Bonding
Philadelphia, PA
Pennsylvania Convention Center
1101 Arch St.
(215) 418-4700
Mike Holt Enterprises, EC&M magazine & Leviton
Email Donna Brown
Phone: (866) 632-2633
[ Download Brochure ]
[ Preview Video ] Download Quicktime Player [FREE]
[ Register Both Days ]
November 9th thru
November 10th
Mike Holt, EC&M & Leviton: Grounding versus Bonding
Seattle, WA
Meydenbauer Center
11100 NE 6th Street
(425) 637-1020
Mike Holt Enterprises, EC&M magazine & Leviton
Email Donna Brown
Phone: (866) 632-2633
[ Download Brochure ]
[ Preview Video ] Download Quicktime Player [FREE]
[ Register Both Days ]
November 16th thru
November 17th
Mike Holt, EC&M & Leviton: Grounding versus Bonding
Chicago, IL
Midwest Conference Center
401 W Lake St
Northlake, IL
(708) 409-2828
Outside Chicago - 7 Miles from Ohare

Mike Holt Enterprises, EC&M magazine & Leviton
Email Donna Brown
Phone: (866) 632-2633
[ Download Brochure ]
[ Preview Video ] Download Quicktime Player [FREE]
[ Register Both Days ]
[ Please Reply With Your Comments ] [ View More Newsletters ]

F o r w a r d   t h i s   N e w s l e t t e r   t o   a   F r i e n d !
Do you have a friend, relative, or colleague who you think would be interested in receiving this free newsletter? If so, we encourage you to forward this message along to them. If you received this email from someone else, and wish to receive your own free issues of our newsletter, sign up today!

C o n t a c t    I n f o r m a t i o n
   
 

Copyright © 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 Mike Holt Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved.
This article is protected by United States copyright and other intellectual property laws and may not be
displayed or published on the internet without the prior written permission of Mike Holt Enterprises, Inc.

http://www.MikeHolt.com     1-888-NEC-CODE (1-888-632-2633)

Comments
  • My Uncle, Sig Sakowitz was a great conductor for the B & O Railroad-he was struck by lightning.


    Reply to this comment

  • Thanks very much for a vivid and informative account.

    The lightning stroke that damaged the oak tree and vaporized the extension cord was one of the rare (I think) high-current strokes. "High current" means that the strike produces a high current that flows through and damages whatever it has attached to on the ground. Many strikes produce no damage at all to the flagpoles or buildings or trees they attach to.

    This particular account is very interesting in that it was witnessed by an educated and interested observer.

    But I'm afraid that I can't agree with the precautions the writer mentions, very simply because we cannot know if they are helpful. You could stand facing a tree that you think is likely to be struck, only to find that your feet are planted firmly along the path of the ground current, which typically does not proceed along and through the earth in an orderly manner. Moreover, the odds are impossibly long that lightning will strike where you think it will.

    Keeping one's feet together while crouching makes it easy to fall over into the mud and impossible to move. At least one of the many different sets of lightning safety rules dictates that one should propel one's self in this manner by hopping to safety. I challenge anyone to try this, lightning storm or not.

    Lightning current typically does not travel through the earth like low-frequency substation fault current. It ionizes a trail through the earth that is similar in shape to that which it takes in air; hopping from one easily broken-down region of the soil to the next.

    One note regarding the previous comment about the unfortunate B & O conductor. The retired railroad engineers who volunteer for a short tourist railway near me have many lightning stories, many concerning ball lightning.

    And as always, thanks to Mr Holt for providing this newsletter.


    Reply to this comment

  • Kinda makes you wonder how Mike can publish things like this that seem to discuss massive ground currents in a responsible manner, yet still be on the side of irresponsible swimming pool installers who thumb their noses at proper bonding methods.

    Many thousands of amps flow during a lightning strike, but when a swimming pool is so poorly bonded that its users are getting shocked by a few amps of earth current, Mike's answer is to blast the local electric utility.

    Bob
    Reply to this comment

  • What a great accounting of lightning. Twice I have had the pleasure to view lightening up close and personal and my respect for >500kv is very real.

    As a side note, Nicola Tesla did a fantastic amount of work on this. Its a wonder to me with this much explosive energy that our government still regards this as science fiction. Back in the 1980's there is an accounting of a mushroom cloud over the Pacific around the Aleutian islands towards the Russian side that recorded no radiation in any band. I always wonder if another government will harness the power of lightning. Any wonder why North Korea has invested in more electricity than it needs via nuclear power....

    It looks to me that with a polarization like a giant capacitor that any path that is the least resistance point is where lightning will strike. The cord in the ground probably did the trick rather than the oak tree. There are certain iron rich trees in Arizona that actually attract energy and dissipate currents through its trunk and roots. Its an amazing tree and evidence is a plenty that this tree saves the forest. Magic in our midst.

    The university of Florida did a study by shooting rockets with small wires attached to ground into clouds ripe with energy to simulate lightning. The key was the least resistance path that led to their success which was underground water pipes, underground electrical tubing and the wire as well. Our worst enemy with regards to this is the laying of underground wire. Our best friend is the old lightning rods which provide a near focused point that has a low impedance path to ground.

    GasMan
    Reply to this comment

  • In the year 1974 I did experience a nasty shock as I was talking over telephone in Trivandrum, India. There was a lightening and all I remeber is a shark shock over to my right ear and right hand. As I was still recovering from learning what had happened, my collegue Mr. Abdul Kalam,now president of Inida, came out of his room saying that a lghtening had been all over his room. At that moment I felt glad to be left surviving by the lightening. I feel much of the energy from the lightening was dissapated inside the room wiring and I must have got a small fraction of the total enegy and that was terrific.

    chengalva sitapati rao
    Reply to this comment


Get notified when new comments are posted here
* Your Email:
 
        
 
Add Your Comments to this Newsletter
* Your Name:
   Your name will appear under your comments.

* Your Email:
   Your email address is not displayed.
* Comments:

Email Notification Options:
Notify me when a reply is posted to this comment
Notify me whenever a comment is posted to this newsletter