This article was posted 09/28/2010 and is most likely outdated.

The Bell Tower Incident at Sigolsheim


Topic - Lightning
Subject - Lightning - Bell Tower Incident at Sigolsheim

September 28, 2010
This newsletter was sent to 16531 newsletter subscribers

Ask a Question |  Continuing EducationQuizzes |  Free Stuff Instructors Products | Seminars | SubscribeUnsubscribe
[ image1 Post Comments | View Comments | Notify Me When Comments Are Added ]  

The Bell Tower Incident at Sigolsheim

Z. A. Hartono & I Robiah
September 2010
With hundreds of thousands of ESE air terminals allegedly installed around the world, the users of these air terminals have every reason to be very concerned about the safety of these buildings and the people that occupy them. This is because the ESE air terminals have also been proven to be very ineffective in France, the country which has produced the most ESE air terminals for the world market.

In May 2009, lightning struck the bell tower of the Saint Pierre and Paul church which is located in the town of Sigolsheim in eastern France. While this incident may seem trivial since many places of worship around the world have been struck by lightning throughout history, it is highly significant due to the size of this bell tower, the climate of the region and the protection that it was provided. The lightning had struck and damaged a stone cross which was installed on one end of the roof while a non-conventional air terminal (i.e. lightning rod) was installed on the other end. An investigation conducted by the French authorities revealed that lightning had not struck the early streamer emission (ESE) air terminal which is claimed to provide protection for the entire church building.

Read the complete report (436 KB)


Click here to post a comment

[ Post Your Comments | View Comments | Notify Me When Comments Are Added ]
[ View More Newsletters ]

Bookmark and Share

Copyright © Mike Holt Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved.
This article is protected by United States copyright and other intellectual property laws and may not be
displayed or published on the internet without the prior written permission of Mike Holt Enterprises, Inc.     1-888-NEC-CODE (1-888-632-2633)


  • Or, well how about then, when it"s time. it's time? It's all about GOD? not anything wlse.!

    Reply to this comment

  • Now you need to publish stories of the failures of conventional Faraday cage lightning protection systems failures. Do you have any stories of ESE terminals being used as weapons against corrections officers in prisons? Or stories of window washers knocking 14" lightning system air terminals off roof parapets where the terminals fell ten stories and pierced the hood of a car parked nearby?

    Eagle 1
    Reply to this comment

  • Ben Franklin was practically elevated to a god like position by the French, whose bell ringers were getting fried regularly, when his lightning rod designs were constructed in France and it sounds like his blunt tipped design gets the job done .

    Don Graff
    Reply to this comment

  • Yes, but how am I going to get back home to 1985 if stuff like this doesn't happen? The next bolt of lighting hitting a church isn't supposed to happen until October 21, 2015, at 4 in the afternoon!

    Marty McFly
    Reply to this comment

  • St. Michael's Church located in the Old Town neighborhood on the near north side in chicago has a very tall clock/ bell tower and a smaller chapel structure both currently being protected by a UL classified lightning protection system with a master label. there are air terminals using typical franklin copper air terminal grounding rods at the main ridge of the sanctuary roof and connected by copper braided cable up multiple sides of the masonry structure to the top of cross at the clock/ bell tower steeple which is approximately 286 ft high and other portions of the church and rectory structure with multiple leads and grounds etc. a smaller connected chapel structure only 50 ft high to the gable ridge is within 100 ft horizontally at the ground plane.

    a massive lightning bolt and fireball was visually seen by numerous people in the local neighborhood to hit the top of the clock/bell tower at the cross and upper ornamental metal surround . the pastor was in his office in the rectory at the time and said the lightning was so bright at the time of the incident that it lit his office brightly thru a large window facing the chapel and courtyard during the darkened sky of a late afternoon thunderstorm. the same lightning strike also hit an unprotected corner stone of the bell tower structure building at approximately 120 ft in elevation and caused large multiple stone spalls to fall to the ground. a single 30 inch tall stone cross at the peak of the end gable of the chapel was also hit and caused the stone cross to break and fall where it was found dangling by the attached copper ground cable and what remained of the copper air terminal rod that had been attached .

    luckily no damage or passerbys were injured; the fire department responded to multiple calls , and went to the top of the wooden steeple structure to inspect and verifiy that there was no fire at the heavy timber wood steeple structure. the copper air terminals were inspected and replaced during a subsequent renovation and exterior restoration. many additional air terminals were added to achieve the UL certification. some of the older air terminals at various areas showed signs of multiple hits and few were melted down considerably.

    i think the old grounding method works rather well given these observed results

    don leone, jr. - architect, chicago
    Reply to this comment

  • The report has clearly brought out the failure of ESE lightning rod in protecting the said installation.It would have been highly instructive,if the authors had included in their report how the protection would have improved vastly, had a properly designed Franklin rod lightning protection system replaced the ESE lightning rod under discussion.(whether it is possible for them to do that here?) Thanks.

    Reply to this comment

Get notified when new comments are posted here
* Your Email:
Add Your Comments to this Newsletter
* Your Name:
   Your name will appear under your comments.

* Your Email:
   Your email address is not displayed.
* Comments:

Email Notification Options:
Notify me when a reply is posted to this comment
Notify me whenever a comment is posted to this newsletter