Mike Holt Enterprises Electrical News Source

Mike Holt's State Rating of the Electrical Industry - 2018

As part of our ongoing focus on electrical safety, we annually update our report that assigns a grade to US States for electrical standards that are mandated state-wide.
How does your state rank?

State-wide mandates considered. The following criteria are all required at the state level for points to be assigned for this report:

  • The NEC® edition adopted (current = 2017 NEC issued on 8/4/2016)
  • Licensing and/or certification required for Apprentice, Journeyman, Master/Contractor, Inspector, and Engineer licenses
  • Continuing Education (CEU or PDH) required for license renewal

What's NOT included in this report.

  • County and Municipality adoptions. We recognize that there are many local adoptions, and that in many cases, county and municipalities adopt the most recent building and electrical codes ahead of their State. The scope of anything other than state-wide mandated requirements is beyond this report. However, due to the feedback we have received, we are working on including some major cities, provided we can rate them on the same criteria.
  • Enforcement or effectiveness. We are unaware of a way to track or correlate enforcement as it relates to rates of incidents or accidents.

Congratulations!

  • The following states have an A+ rating: Arkansas, Colorado, Iowa, Maine, Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oregon, South Dakota, Wyoming.
  • We applaud all those states, counties and local municipalities that continue to set high standards in electrical safety.

We'd appreciate your feedback.
If you have any updated information that you feel would change our rankings on this year's report, please post your comment - we appreciate your input to help keep this analysis accurate and current.

The Chart below shows the rankings. If there is a green up arrow next to the state name, it indicates an improvement in grade over the last 5 years from 2014 to 2018; a down red arrowindicates a decline.
For history and details of how grades are calculated, click here.
Note: All 12 points are required for an A+ grade.

Note: Some of the data on this newsletter has been updated since it was first sent out on March 29 based on feedback and new NEC adoptions. Also note that a state will be included on this report if they have adopted a version of the NEC, even though the updated NEC might not be effective as of the publication of this newsletter.

STATE GRADE 2014 GRADE 2015 GRADE 2016 GRADE 2017 GRADE 2018
ALABAMA C+ B- C+ C+ B
ALASKA A A A A A
ARIZONA F F F F F
ARKANSAS A+ A+ A+ A A+
CALIFORNIA A- A- A- A- A-
COLORADO A+ A+ A+ A A+
CONNECTICUT A- A- A- A- A-
D.C. C+ C+ C+ C C
DELAWARE A- A- A- A A
FLORIDA B- B B B- B
GEORGIA B- B- B- C+ B-
HAWAII C+ C+ C C- C+
IDAHO A A A A- A
ILLINOIS D D D F F
INDIANA D+ D+ D+ D D
IOWA A A+ A+ A A+
KANSAS F F F F F
KENTUCKY A A A A- A-
LOUISIANA C+ C+ C+ C C+
MAINE A+ A+ A+ A A+
MARYLAND C C C+ C C
MASSACHUSETTS A- A- A- A- A-
MICHIGAN A A+ A+ A A
MINNESOTA A+ A+ A+ A+ A+
MISSISSIPPI D D D F F
MISSOURI F F F F F
MONTANA A A A A- A-
NEBRASKA A+ A+ A+ A A+
NEVADA D D D F F
NEW HAMPSHIRE A- A- A- B+ A-
NEW JERSEY A- A- A- A- A-
NEW MEXICO A- A- A- B+ A-
NEW YORK D+ D+ D+ C- C+
NORTH CAROLINA B B B B B+
NORTH DAKOTA A+ A+ A+ A A+
OHIO B B+ B+ B- B
OKLAHOMA A A A A- A-
OREGON A+ A+ A+ A A+
PENNSYLVANIA C C C C- C+
RHODE ISLAND A- A- A- B+ B+
SOUTH CAROLINA B- B- B- B- B-
SOUTH DAKOTA A+ A+ A+ A A+
TENNESSEE B- B- C+ C B
TEXAS A- A- A- B+ A-
UTAH A A A A A
VERMONT A- A- A- B+ A-
VIRGINIA A- A- A- B+ B+
WASHINGTON A A A A- A
WEST VIRGINIA B B B B B
WISCONSIN A- A- A- B+ A-
WYOMING A+ A+ A+ A A+

Click here for history and details of how the points are assigned.

NOTE: Some of the data on this newsletter has been updated since it was first sent out on March 29 based on feedback and state adoptions of a newer NEC.

Comments
  • It would be interesting to see how each state handles low voltage contractors as well on this chart.

    Christopher Hobbs  April 16 2018, 4:04 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • I must have missed last year's rating, but in 2016, Oregon was listed as having an "A+" for the years 2007 through 2015, now they've only got an "A"? Oregon DOES require licensing of their apprentices, I'm on the local apprenticeship board and a representative to the state board meeting. All the apprentices that work for me must have licenses, or they don't work. Where can I find the report from last year to determine why Oregon received an "A-"?

    Larry Bohn  April 1 2018, 1:54 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • Tennessee has adopted the 2017 NEC to go in effect 10/1/18.

    Don P.  March 30 2018, 1:28 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • I am surprised that Florida has been rated as a "B." They are always a code cycle behind - their current NEC is the 2014 edition and there are no state requirements for a journeyman electrician.

    If you want to start your own business as an electrical contractor, there are plenty who will "include" you under their license. Florida allows a licensed electrical contractor to have four different businesses under the same license number.

    Lastly, they only guarantee their work for one year.

    It's a sad state of affairs when all of this rates as a "B".

    J Peer  March 30 2018, 10:27 am EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • MN does require Apprentice license.

    Justin  March 30 2018, 12:21 am EDT
    Reply to this comment

  • I think when you view a chart like this you also have to keep in mind the volume of work being done in those states. We find in our business endeavors in other states that certain inspectors are not as well versed as others. If you havre minimal work to inspect, you can go over it more thoroughly. On the other side of this, if you are swamped with inspections you cannot dedicate as much time as you would like to any particular project.

    Bill Sampson  March 29 2018, 11:55 pm EDT
    Reply to this comment


Get notified when new comments are posted here
* Your Email:
 
        
 
Add Your Comments to this Newsletter
* Your Name:
   Your name will appear under your comments.

* Your Email:
   Your email address is not displayed.
* Comments:

Email Notification Options:
Notify me when a reply is posted to this comment
Notify me whenever a comment is posted to this newsletter