Mike Holt Business Newlsetter Series
Mike Holt
Estimating is a skill that can make or break a career or company. Understanding the estimating and bidding processes is essential for your business to remain profitable.

This is newsletter #23 in the series. If you have missed prior newsletters, and are enjoying the series, we encourage you to purchase the complete Electrical Estimating Program. Click on the coupon at the bottom of this page.

The Estimating Process - Plans and Specifications Review

Now that you have collected all the bid documents, it's time to begin reviewing the specification documents to understand the details of the job. Carefully read the specifications documents and all notes on the drawings so that you have a clear understanding of the scope of the project and the bid requirements before you begin the actual take-off. Make notes of any important details that you need to remember while completing the estimate. Take note of any alternate options for material or installation methods and allowances to be included in the bid. If you are bidding an entire project identify any subcontractors that must be used or brand restrictions. If you're providing a small part of a larger make sure you can meet the insurance and bonding requirements before you do all the work to submit a bid that you don’t qualify to perform.

If the owner is supplying material, such as a fixture package, remember to deduct only the material cost of the item(s) supplied not the labor, profit, or overhead. You will still incur the same costs of handling, storing, installation, labor for any warranty, and all of the other overhead costs and risk factors associated with that material.

Plans
Reviewing plans can be a daunting task. Plans are often crowded with details that are difficult to identify and important to the final price. This is one area that on screen takeoff software excels. Make sure to make multiple passes over the drawings so that you catch the little details that you may miss on the first review. Take a close look at all drawing legends, details, notations, and symbols. If you see something on the legend that's not on the drawing, take care to ensure you didn’t overlook something. Some projects will have device and fixture counts available with the bid documents. These are a great way to double check your work and make sure you didn’t miss something. Watch for control wiring, underground wiring, area lighting, signs, and outdoor equipment that may not be a normal part of the job. Become familiar with the entire installation and check for any special or unusual features such as elevated ceilings. Check to see if proper working space is provided for the electrical equipment, look for the locations of utilities, and so on.

Case Study No. 1: A friend of mine, who was just getting started in business, did not read the note on the drawing that required him to replace 180 ft of 4/0 AWG service conductors with 500 kcmil service conductors.
The Result: He underbid the job by $4,000 on a $35,000 job, and won the job losing $4,000!

Case Study No. 2: The drawings indicated that the electrical contractor was required to install three of the owner’s fixtures. The contractor didn’t have sufficient information on the fixtures and figured 3 hours for each fixture during the bid. The actual fixtures weighed over 500 lb each and required three men three days to install them!
The Result: He won the bid and lost 15 hours of labor.

Case Study No. 3: During the estimating takeoff process, a symbol for a lighting fixture was overlooked by the electrical contractor. The owner was providing the fixtures but the wiring and labor costs for the installation was $125.00 each.
The Result: There were 40 of these fixtures indicated on the plans throughout the building so the contractors lost $5,000!


Specifications
Underline, circle, or highlight important and/or unusual items that can affect the estimate. Some estimators will circle these items before doing the take-off, and only highlight them after taking care of the item in the estimate. Determine who is responsible for painting exposed conduits, trenching, backfill, concrete work, patching, cleanup, temporary power, and so on. Find out if the use of special equipment or overtime is required. Don’t take anything for granted. You may be able to work some of these details out after you’re on the job with other sub-contractors but always assume you're going to pay to have them done when determining your cost.

Case Study No. 1: According to the specifications a contractor was required to provide a video projector. He priced a similar brand and model that cost $5,000 because he didn't make the time to price out the exact model specified.
The Result: The owner required the exact model specified in the plans not the proposed alternate. The specified model cost $18,000 not $5,000 resulting in a $13,000 loss!



Specifications Checklist
To help you keep track of the drawings and specifications details, complete the Specifications Checklist worksheet as you proceed through the estimate. You will need this information at different stages of the process. Make pertinent notes such as scope and wiring methods for reference as you complete the various steps of the estimate. Use the list below to create a checklist of important items to be checked off when the estimate is near completion. This list is best kept on a spreadsheet or paper separate from the bid so that you can check it off as you go through the bid documents.

Specifications Checklist
Labor-Unit Adjustment
1. Building Conditions  
2. Change Orders  
3. Concealed and Exposed Wiring  
4. Construction Schedule  
5. Job Factors  
6. Labor Skill (Efficiency)  
7. Ladder and Scaffold  
8. Management  
9. Material  
10. Off Hours and Occupied  
11. Overtime  
12. Remodel (Old Work)  
13. Repetitive Factor  
14. Restrictive Working Conditions  
15. Shift Work  
16. Teamwork  
17. Temperature  
18. Weather and Humidity  
Labor Adjustment
Additional Labor
1. As-Built Plans  
2. Demolition  
3. Energized Parts  
4. Environmental Hazards  
5. Excavation, Trenching, and Backfill  
6. Fire Seals  
7. Job Location  
8. Match-Up of Existing Equipment  
9. Miscellaneous Material Items  
10. Mobilization (Start-up)  
11. Nonproductive Labor  
12. OSHA Compliance  
13. Plans and Specifications  
14. Public Safety  
15. Security  
16. Shop Time  
17. Site Conditions  
18. Subcontract Supervision  
19. Temporary and/or Standby Power  
Hour Adder
Direct Job Expenses
1. As-Built Plans $
2. Business and Occupational Fees $
3. Engineering Drawings $
4. Equipment Rental $
5. Field Office Expenses $
6. Fire Seals $
7. Warranty $
8. Insurance—Special $
9. Miscellaneous $
10. Mobilization $
11. OSHA Compliance $
12. Out-of-Town Expenses $
13. Parking Fees $
14. Permits/Inspection Fees $
15. Public Safety $
16. Recycle Fees $
17. Storage and Handling $
18. Subcontract: $
19. Supervision Cost $
20. Temporary Wiring: $
21. Lighting $
22. Power $
23. Maintenance $
24. Testing $
25. Trash $
26. Utility Cost $
Total Direct Cost $
Other Final Costs
1. Allowances/Contingency $
2. Back-Charges $
3. Bond $
4. Completion Penalty $
5. Finance Cost $
6. Gross Receipts or Net Profit Tax $
7. Inspection Problems $
8. Retainage $
Total Other Cost $
Other Considerations
1. Conductor Size—Minimum?  
2. Raceway Size—Minimum?  
3. Control Wiring Responsibility?  
4. Concrete cutting and/or Core Boring Responsibility?  
5. Demolition Responsibility?  
6. Excavation/Backfill Responsibility?  
7. Painting Responsibility?  
8. Patching Responsibility?  
9. Special Equipment?  
10. Specification Grade Devices or Fittings?  

• • •

We'd love to hear from you about this series, and the ways you're using it. Send us your comments and feedback by clicking on Post a Comment below. Look out for the next part in this series a month from now, and please share with your colleagues.


Comments
    No comments to display

Get notified when new comments are posted here
* Your Email:
 
        
 
Add Your Comments to this Newsletter
* Your Name:
   Your name will appear under your comments.

* Your Email:
   Your email address is not displayed.
* Comments:

Email Notification Options:
Notify me when a reply is posted to this comment
Notify me whenever a comment is posted to this newsletter